Reviews for 'Improve YouTube!' 🎧 (For YouTube & Video)
'Improve YouTube!' 🎧 (For YouTube & Video) by code-for-charity, ImprovedTube
Review by tiny dragon
Rated 2 out of 5
by tiny dragon, 10 months agoI want to like this extension so badly. It seems so promising. It's free and made by volunteers and open source.
But I've been trying it off and on for months now, and during that time I've tried it on 4 different browsers and 3 different operating systems (two desktop, one mobile), and it's always broken in multiple ways, and it always absolutely murders Firefox's performance.
Yes, I tried disabling other youtube and adblock extensions. And I tried running Improve Youtube alone and in private mode, with no other extensions. No dice.
And no, my computer is not a potato (nor is my phone). And this is the only addon that's been causing me problems like this.
This extension is just extremely broken, all the time, always. It feels like a super early alpha release, not a finished addon.
You can report issues on github, but even *if* that leads to the issue getting fixed in a halfway timely manner, there are always additional issues occuring at the same time.
There's no predicting which options in the settings menu will work, or which will break even more things, and seemingly aaaaaaall of them tank the browser's performance.
I genuinely don't understand how this addon is getting good reviews. I can imagine it might become an incredible addon eventually, if the tsunami of problems is ever overcome, and I really hope it does, but for right now... Don't waste your time, like I did. There are alternatives to this addon that actually work, and reliably so.
I'd only recommend installing this addon if you're wanting to get involved in developing it, by way of a hobby project.
But I've been trying it off and on for months now, and during that time I've tried it on 4 different browsers and 3 different operating systems (two desktop, one mobile), and it's always broken in multiple ways, and it always absolutely murders Firefox's performance.
Yes, I tried disabling other youtube and adblock extensions. And I tried running Improve Youtube alone and in private mode, with no other extensions. No dice.
And no, my computer is not a potato (nor is my phone). And this is the only addon that's been causing me problems like this.
This extension is just extremely broken, all the time, always. It feels like a super early alpha release, not a finished addon.
You can report issues on github, but even *if* that leads to the issue getting fixed in a halfway timely manner, there are always additional issues occuring at the same time.
There's no predicting which options in the settings menu will work, or which will break even more things, and seemingly aaaaaaall of them tank the browser's performance.
I genuinely don't understand how this addon is getting good reviews. I can imagine it might become an incredible addon eventually, if the tsunami of problems is ever overcome, and I really hope it does, but for right now... Don't waste your time, like I did. There are alternatives to this addon that actually work, and reliably so.
I'd only recommend installing this addon if you're wanting to get involved in developing it, by way of a hobby project.
897 reviews
- Rated 5 out of 5by AThKORU, 3 days ago
- Rated 3 out of 5by epicgamer, 15 days ago
- Rated 3 out of 5by Re'soul, 25 days agorandomly causes youtube to stop working due to "connection not secure" with the only way to fix it being to clear cookies and site data for youtube also since i started using this add on firefox will randomly freeze up and will often crash and forcefully close all windows, i've never had this happen with any other firefox add on just this one so for those two reasons this add on is kinda unusable due to how buggy it is and how annoying those bugs are due to how often they happen, over all the add on is fine would actually be really good if the issues were fixed but pretty much everything if not everything this add on does can be found in other more stable add ons that don't randomly brake youtube or firefox
Developer response
posted 3 days agohi, like other persistent open source projects you can find 1000s of issues and wishes done here https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues . Your cookie issue was not posted there yet hence it may be rare or mistake, eitherway you may have a good experience using our bug report template there with some more specificity (often required)
'if not everything' the math doesn't work there, since we have very specific features. - Rated 5 out of 5by SmokeySalmon, 25 days ago
- Rated 1 out of 5by foundinwords, a month agoBasically unusable, as it slowed my browser nearly to a halt, especially when on Youtube.
Developer response
posted 3 days agoplease be specific enough and use our bug-report template if possible. - Rated 5 out of 5by ismetsoner, a month ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Fen1ma, a month ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Rust, 2 months ago
- Rated 2 out of 5by Firefox user 13651036, 2 months ago
- Rated 1 out of 5by Monkey Do, 2 months agoOn MOBILE doesn't work at all. No matter which of the options I toogled on or off. Firefox v152.
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 13514584, 2 months ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by mdfhnPQMOSnhvk, 2 months ago
- Rated 4 out of 5by Firefox user 20007710, 2 months agoGenerally amazing and great features. But I have 2 features I'd like to ask for. 1 being a separate grid size options for shorts and for the side bar on video player. While I'm not doom scrolling shorts, I'm sub'd to a few channels that put out great quality shorts that'd I'd like to view. Shorts are just really large compared to normal thumbnails. It's a balancing issue choosing between smaller thumbnails vs huge shorts. 2, Sidebar thumbnails feel huge after installing this extension. If you could include an option to reduce thumbnail size and increase video title space, that'd be great. But 2 is honestly just personal preference. I'm using Zen Browser if that makes any difference.
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 14604465, 2 months ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 20003153, 2 months ago
- Rated 1 out of 5by tokumei, 3 months agoWhile watching videos on YouTube, playback occasionally stops on its own. I am aware that the website has a feature that stops playback after 15 minutes of inactivity, but this seems to be a different issue.
In addition, videos sometimes stop playing when I switch to another browser tab. In those cases, playback resumes as soon as I return to the YouTube tab. The behavior is somewhat similar to the YouTube mobile app, where playback may stop when the screen or app is switched.
Both issues tend to occur near the beginning of a video rather than throughout the entire playback session.
I did not experience these problems while the add-on was disabled, so I suspect there may be some compatibility issue between the add-on and a web service or browser feature. - Rated 5 out of 5by felda9000, 3 months ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 13122458, 3 months ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by THX1138, 3 months agoAbsolutes MUST-HAVE. Theme-Farben werden wieder angezeigt. Leider im Kanal noch weiße Stellen! Trotzdem: Vielen Dank!